Wastewater Gardens - logo 
Wastewater Gardens®

A beautiful and natural wastewater
recycling system



Treatment efficiency

      Constructed wetlands with horizontal subsurface flow usually provide high treatment effect in terms of removal of organics (BOD5, COD) and suspended solids (SS). The removal of nitrogen and phosphorus is lower but comparable with conventional treatment technologies which do not include special nutrient removal step.

      Treatment efficiency of constructed wetlands with horizontal subsurface flow in terms of concentrations are summarized in tables 1-5. (Vymazal J.: The use of sub-surface constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment in the Czech Republic: 10 years experience. Ecological Engineering 18/2002, pp. 633-646)

Table 1. Average influent and effluent concentration (mg/l) and removal efficiencies (%) of organics (BOD5) in horizontal, subsurface flow vegetated beds in different countries
Country Influent concentration Effluent concentration Efficiency
Czech Republic 87,2 10,5 88,0
Denmark and UK 97,0 13,1 86,5
North America 27,5 8,6 68,5
Germany-L. Saxony 248 42 83,0
Germany-Bavaria 106 21,6 79,6
Poland 7,65 4,10 46,4
Slovenia 107 11,3 89,0
Sweden 80,5 5,9 92,7


Table 2. Average influent and effluent concentration (mg/l) and removal efficiencies (%) of organics (COD) in horizontal, subsurface flow vegetated beds in different countries
Country Influent concentration Effluent concentration Efficiency
Czech Republic 211,0 53,0 75,0
Denmark 264,0 64,7 75,0
Germany-L. Saxony 430,0 133 69,0
Germany-Bavaria 234,0 69,4 70,3
Poland 283,0 101 64,3
Slovenia 200,0 35,7 82,0


Table 3. Average influent and effluent concentration (mg/l) and removal efficiencies (%) of suspended solids in horizontal, subsurface flow vegetated beds in different countries
Country Influent concentration Effluent concentration Efficiency
Czech Republic 64,8 10,2 84,3
Denmark and UK 98,6 13,6 86,2
North America 48,2 10,3 78,6
Poland 140 38,6 77,4


Table 4. Average influent and effluent concentration (mg/l) and removal efficiencies (%) of total phosphorus in horizontal, subsurface flow vegetated beds in different countries
Country Influent concentration Effluent concentration Efficiency
Czech Republic 6,57 3,22 51,0
Denmark and UK 8,60 6,30 26,7
North America 4,41 2,97 32,7
Germany-L. Saxony 11,4 3,99 65.0
Poland 7,65 4,10 46,4
Sweden 5,03 2,10 58,3


Table 5. Average influent and effluent concentration (mg/l) and removal efficiencies (%) of total nitrogen in horizontal, subsurface flow vegetated beds in different countries
Country Influent concentration Effluent concentration Efficiency
Czech Republic 46,4 27,1 41,6
Denmark 36,6 20,9 42,9
North America 18,9 8,4 55,6
Germany-L. Saxony 115,0 59,8 48,0
Poland 46,1 34,8 24,5
Sweden 25,3 15,1 40,3


      The well designed and constructed Wastewater Gardens® system complies with Polish environmental regulations, European standards, United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), and German ATV. It is confirmed by recent results from the pilot Wastewater Garden in Krempna. The measurements are made for the purposes of master thesis research done by students of the Faculty of Surveying and Environmental Engineering of the Mining and Metallurgy University in Krakow. The average results from first three months of the system's operation are presented in Table 6. It shows that effluent quality limits are met, even though the plants were still young and not full developed. Higher efficiency rates are expected in the course of time as the plants' roots get more established.


Table 6. Results from the pilot Wastewater Gardens® system in Krempna
Parameter Influent concentration Effluent concentration Limit value*
BOD5 55,0 mg O2/l 11,0 mg O2/l 40 mg O2/l
COD 88,0 mg O2/l 32,0 mg O2/l 150 mg O2/l
SS 74,5 mg/l 49,5 mg/l 50 mg/l
Total N 73,7 mg N/l 24,6 mg N/l 30 mg N/l
Total P 7,2 mg P/l 2,0 mg P/l 5 mg P/l
* according to Polish environmental regulations


      Figure 1 presents comparison of removal efficiency of Wastewater Garden subsurface flow systems with average North American surface and subsurface flow wetlands.


Source: Nelson M., Tredwell R.: New Paradigms: "Wastewater Gardens", creating urban oases and greenbelts by productive use of the nutrients and water in domestic sewage. UNEP Conference on Cities as Sustainable Ecosystems, April 15-16, 2002. Environmental Technology Centre, Murdoch University, Perth, West Australia.


      Figure 2 presents results from the pilot program Wastewater Gardens at Birdwood Downs homestead, Derby, West Australia, September 2000 - December 2001.
Source: Nelson M., Tredwell R.: New Paradigms: "Wastewater Gardens", creating urban oases and greenbelts by productive use of the nutrients and water in domestic sewage. UNEP Conference on Cities as Sustainable Ecosystems, April 15-16, 2002. Environmental Technology Centre, Murdoch University, Perth, West Australia.



© 2002 Carpathian Heritage Society
& Natural Systems, Dr Andrzej Czech